Leaves (19th Century) | Metropolitan Museum of Art / Public Domain
Scholars of medieval German love-lyric call the seasonal opening of many songs the Natureingang: a few stock lines about May, flowers, and birdsong, or else winter cold, that frame a song about love. Susan Stewart uses the word as the title of one of the “Plague Octets” early in Bramble (University of Chicago Press, 2026). It is almost May, a fisherman holds up two brown trout, and skunk cabbage is coming up by the banks. The poem ends: “One day this song will be merely / puzzling. ‘What did they mean by a mask?’ they’ll say.” Stewart is having some scholarly fun with an old convention, though the spring she describes is the first spring of the pandemic.
Stewart has spent four decades writing some of the most influential criticism we have on what lyric poetry is for. In Poetry and the Fate of the Senses (2001) she argued, roughly, that poems work against the isolation of the mind and help us make out other people from inside our own solitude. Bramble, her seventh collection and a finalist for this year’s National Book Award in poetry, begins with a poem called “In the Dark,” which asks, “why do I love the truth?” In the poems that follow, she tries to make herself visible to readers in just that way.
The title draws on two traditions. The epigraph to the first section, “Mirror,” is Judges 9:15, the end of Jotham’s fable. Abimelech has killed his seventy brothers “upon one stone,” and Jotham, the one who escaped, tells the men of Shechem a story about trees looking for a king. The olive, the fig, and the vine each refuse the crown. Only the bramble accepts, with a condition attached: “put your trust in my shadow: and if not, let fire come out of the bramble, and devour the cedars of Lebanon.” A bramble gives almost no shade, so the promise is an empty one.
“Mirror” is the book’s most public section. Its octets record the first year of the pandemic: masks, drone photographs of the mass graves on Hart Island, protests, a curfew, a looter in a lawn chair beside a charred mannequin. In “November” the screen is “our threshing machine, / where I type these lines in loathing.” “Curfew” ends on an etymology, “From / the old French: cuevrefu, to cover fire.” Stewart never mentions Jotham here, but with the epigraph in mind I found it hard not to think of the bramble’s threat.
Then come the “Psalm Octets,” versions of the penitential psalms written for the composer James Primosch, who died in April 2021 before he could finish the song cycle. The seven are traditionally 6, 32, 38, 51, 102, 130, and 143, but Stewart replaces 51 with 52. In place of the Miserere, David’s plea for forgiveness after Bathsheba, which opens “Have mercy upon me, O God,” she gives us the psalm against the “mighty man” who boasts in mischief, and her version begins, “The little minds brag at the meeting, / while the rest yawn and read their mail.” With that swap, a psalm of confession gives way to one about another man’s pride, and the psalms stay close to the public satire around them. Near its end, Psalm 52 has its speaker say, “I am like a green olive tree in the house of God.” Stewart’s version ends, “I was meant / to be a sapling, supple and green, / and waiting alone in that wind.” In Jotham’s fable the olive is the first tree asked to rule, and it declines. Stewart leaves the connection unstated, allowing the biblical fable and the psalm to illuminate one another.
In traditional ballads the briar grows out of a grave. In many versions of the folk song “Barbara Allen,” a rose springs from one lover’s grave and a briar from the other’s, and the two twine together in a true lovers’ knot. Stewart comes closest to that image in “The Dune,” her adaptation of Victor Hugo’s “Paroles sur la dune.” Hugo’s poem ends with the blue thistle of the sands flowering by the sea, and Stewart puts the flower inside a thicket: “When you saw the blue flower / far within the bramble, / you knew at last / the permanence of sand.” In the last stanza the speaker and the “you” change places: “And I was the ghost, and / you were the tomb, / then you were the ghost, / and I was the tomb.” In the ballad, the knot gives the dead lovers the union they missed in life. “The Dune” has the two graves but no union. The “I” and the “you” take turns being the dead one and the one who holds the dead, and the blue flower stays out of reach inside the bramble. I take the bramble in this poem to be grief, which keeps the mourner from the comfort the old song offers. The borrowing also lets Stewart mourn without telling her own story. Although the ‘Psalm Octets’ are dedicated to the memory of composer James Primosch, Stewart seldom makes the circumstances of her mourning explicit, even as ‘Ps. 143’ looks back from ‘this / posthumous time’ to the days ‘when we were woven together.’
In “Briar,” the middle section, the bramble stands mostly for the difficulty of making things. The epigraphs are Spenser’s bramble bush, where birds tune their song to a waterfall, and Pip in Great Expectations, who “struggled through the alphabet as if it had been a bramble-bush; getting considerably worried and scratched by every letter.” In The Poet’s Freedom (2011), Stewart argued that freedom is something artists make, by giving rules to their practice and choosing within finite conditions. The poems in “Briar” try that idea out on small subjects. “A Lever,” whose lines narrow and widen on the page like the hourglass it mentions, follows its rule down into a pit and comes up with a pun: “though pit is the start / of pity.” “The Music Box” asks who “gave up / on playing / and packed the pulse / beneath a lid,” then says, “Here is the device / for tamping wild grief.” In On Longing (1984), Stewart read the miniature as a figure for the inner life. A music box fits that description, and so, I think, do the eight-line octets of “Mirror,” which hold a year of public grief in a very small space.
“Channel” is a single long poem, written for Ann Hamilton’s installation and performance habitus, which follows water from a spring to the sea. Hamilton’s piece was about cloth and the hands that have worked it, and Stewart’s poem keeps that labor in view. She works in the nursery rhyme “Monday’s child is fair of face,” the old housework calendar (“Monday, washing / Tuesday, ironing”), and a list of vanished kinds of work: “The menders and the gleaners—gone, / the trappers and the hunters ~ / the darners and the typists.” Much of it was done by hand, and the poem lists it as lost. “The river only mirrors / changing sky,” Stewart writes, echoing the first section’s title, and later, “The sky cannot mirror the river.” In these lines the water shows the sky and nothing else, so the memory of all that work, which the river carries, never appears on its surface.
I study John Clare, and reading Bramble alongside his poems of hedges and field margins changes how its bramble looks. In Clare’s work, the bramble is hardly ever a tyrant. It grows on the margins, and enclosure destroys it. “The Mores” lists the losses, among them the mulberry bushes “grubbed and done” and the “hedgrow-briars” that once overjoyed flower-lovers, and it describes the fields divided up “In little parcels little minds to please.” The tyrants in that poem are landowners: “Each little tyrant with his little sign / Shows where man claims earth glows no more divine.” When Stewart’s little minds brag at their meeting, I hear Clare. In his poems the people who behave like Abimelech are the ones putting up fences, and the bramble belongs to the commons they enclose.
Clare’s thickets also have to be endured. In “The Nightingale’s Nest” he has spent hours searching, “on hands and knees through matted thorns,” before he finds the nest: “there, put that bramble bye / Nay, trample on its branches and get near.” Once he has found it, he backs away: “We’ll leave it as we found it.” In “The Horseshoe Crab” Stewart turns over a living crab among the empty shells, “touching only your outline,” admits that “What I can know about you hardly matters,” and watches it go back into the surf. She also knows the crab’s blood is collected for laboratory use: “Your book-shaped lamellae flap / and pump your bright blue blood / all the way to the lab.” “When it comes to who / is saving whom,” she writes, “who can say?” Clare’s promise in the nightingale poem would sit well in hers: “We will not plunder music of its dower / Nor turn this spot of happiness to thrall.”
In “Decay” Clare writes, “The bramble’s dwindled to a bramble / O poesy is on its wane.” For Clare, a bramble that was nothing more than a bramble meant that poetry had left him. Stewart doesn’t seem to share that fear. In “Channel” a paperboy, his bike, and the alder leaves are reflected in the river until the wind, “like a palm / across a slate, / erases boy and / leaves and bike, / and all is literal again,” and the poem moves on downstream. In the same way, Stewart lets the bramble stay a plant while it carries what Judges, the ballads, and Dickens put into it.
I have some reservations. The “Plague Octets” are tied to their moment by design, and a few, “November” in particular, read more like opinion writing than like the psalms that follow. Stewart anticipates this in “Natureingang,” but those poems will still date. Some of the “Minor Musics” are slight. “Channel,” written for Hamilton’s installation and performance, loses something on the page, and its refrains probably work better spoken aloud in that space.
Yet in poems such as ‘The Dune,’ ‘The Horseshoe Crab,’ and ‘Ps. 52,’ Stewart realizes much of what she has spent four decades arguing lyric poetry can accomplish. They let us hear another person clearly and leave the reader a good deal to put together. The winners will be announced on November 18, and the other poetry finalists are Victoria Chang, Carolina Ebeid, Brenda Hillman, and Fady Joudah. Whatever the judges decide, I expect to keep going back to Bramble, especially to the poems where Stewart looks closely at a single creature or plant.



